Marketing Writers: Are You Wasting Your Money?

Many businesses struggle to create marketing content that truly resonates with their target audience. Are you tired of seeing your carefully crafted words fall flat, failing to drive the engagement and conversions you need?

Key Takeaways

  • Hire writers with demonstrated expertise in your specific industry, not just general writing skills, to improve content relevance.
  • Implement a structured content review process with subject matter experts to ensure accuracy and credibility of marketing materials.
  • Track content performance metrics like time on page and bounce rate to identify areas where writers need additional training or support.

The Problem: Content That Doesn’t Convert

Too often, marketing teams churn out blog posts, articles, and social media updates that simply don’t achieve their goals. The writing might be grammatically correct and even aesthetically pleasing, but it lacks the punch needed to capture attention and drive action. This is because many businesses treat writers as interchangeable cogs in a content machine, rather than recognizing the specialized skills needed to create truly effective marketing materials.

What Went Wrong First?

Before we cracked the code, we made our share of mistakes. Initially, we focused solely on hiring writers with strong writing skills, regardless of their industry knowledge. We figured, “a good writer is a good writer,” right? Wrong. We assigned a project about changes to Georgia’s lien laws (O.C.G.A. Section 44-14-360) to a talented writer who primarily wrote about travel. While the writing itself was polished, the final product lacked the depth and nuance required to address the legal complexities and, frankly, scared potential clients away.

Another failed approach involved relying solely on keyword research to guide content creation. We stuffed articles with keywords, hoping to appease the Google gods, but the resulting content was clunky, unnatural, and provided little value to readers. Bounce rates soared, and time on page plummeted. According to a recent IAB report on content consumption trends IAB, audiences are increasingly discerning, demanding content that is both informative and engaging. Keyword stuffing simply doesn’t cut it anymore.

The Solution: Expertise-Driven Content Creation

The key to unlocking effective marketing content lies in prioritizing expertise. Here’s our step-by-step approach:

  1. Identify Your Content Needs: Before hiring anyone, clearly define the types of content you need and the specific expertise required. Are you creating blog posts about personal injury law near the Fulton County Courthouse? Do you need white papers on the latest advancements in cloud computing? Or are you looking for compelling ad copy to run on Meta Ads Manager? The more specific you are, the better you can target your search.
  1. Source Subject Matter Experts: Don’t just look for writers; seek out individuals with deep knowledge and experience in your industry. This might mean hiring former industry professionals who have transitioned into writing, partnering with freelance writers who specialize in your niche, or even training your in-house experts to become better communicators. I had a client last year who had a fantastic in-house engineer who was passionate about writing. With some coaching on SEO best practices and content structure, he became one of their most valuable content creators.
  1. Implement a Robust Review Process: Even the most knowledgeable writers can benefit from a second set of eyes. Establish a content review process that involves subject matter experts who can verify the accuracy and completeness of the information presented. This is especially crucial in highly regulated industries like finance and healthcare.
  1. Provide Ongoing Training and Support: Invest in training your writers on the latest marketing trends, SEO best practices, and content strategy. This will help them stay up-to-date and create content that is both informative and effective. We regularly provide our team with access to eMarketer reports eMarketer and industry webinars to keep their skills sharp.
  1. Measure and Analyze Results: Track the performance of your content using analytics tools like Google Analytics 4. Pay attention to metrics like organic traffic, time on page, bounce rate, and conversion rates. This data will help you identify what’s working and what’s not, allowing you to refine your content strategy and improve your results.

A Concrete Case Study: Boosting Conversions for a Law Firm

We implemented this expertise-driven approach for a personal injury law firm located near the intersection of Peachtree Street and Lenox Road in Buckhead, Atlanta. The firm was struggling to attract qualified leads through its website. Their existing blog posts were generic and didn’t address the specific concerns of potential clients.

Here’s what we did:

  • Hired a writer with experience in personal injury law: We found a freelance writer who had previously worked as a paralegal at a personal injury firm. She understood the legal jargon and the emotional needs of clients.
  • Focused on specific topics: Instead of writing general articles about “car accidents,” we created content on topics like “What to do after a car accident on I-85” and “How to file a claim with State Farm after a rear-end collision.”
  • Incorporated local references: We mentioned specific landmarks, like Piedmont Hospital, and referred to relevant Georgia statutes, such as O.C.G.A. Section 51-1-1.
  • Implemented a review process: An attorney at the firm reviewed every blog post to ensure accuracy and legal compliance.

The Results:

Within three months, the firm saw a 35% increase in organic traffic to its website. More importantly, the conversion rate from website visitors to qualified leads increased by 20%. The firm attributed this success to the more targeted and informative content.

The Importance of Understanding Your Audience

Here’s what nobody tells you: even the most expertly written content will fall flat if you don’t understand your audience. You need to know their pain points, their questions, and their motivations. What keeps them up at night? What are they searching for online? What kind of language do they use?

For example, if you’re marketing to small business owners in the Marietta Square Historic District, your messaging should be different than if you’re targeting enterprise-level clients in Midtown. You need to speak their language and address their specific needs.

We once created a series of blog posts for a software company targeting CFOs. The initial drafts were filled with technical jargon and focused on the features of the software. The CFOs didn’t care about the features; they cared about the bottom line. We had to rewrite the content to focus on the business benefits and use language that resonated with financial professionals. To achieve similar results, consider how to connect with your audience ethically.

The Role of AI in Content Creation

While AI writing tools can be helpful for generating ideas and creating outlines, they should not be used as a substitute for human writers with expertise. AI-generated content often lacks the nuance, creativity, and emotional intelligence needed to truly connect with an audience. Think of AI as a tool to assist writers, not replace them. Consider how to track meaningful engagement metrics to gauge the effectiveness of your content.

One limitation to acknowledge: even with expert writers, content marketing is a long game. You might not see immediate results. It takes time to build trust, establish authority, and rank in search engines. Be patient, stay consistent, and keep refining your approach based on data and feedback. For indie filmmakers, marketing from zero can be daunting, but persistence pays off.

By prioritizing expertise, implementing a robust review process, and understanding your audience, you can unlock the power of content marketing and achieve your business goals.

Stop churning out generic content and start investing in expertise. Hire writers who truly understand your industry and your audience, and you’ll see a significant improvement in your marketing results.

How do I find writers with expertise in my specific industry?

Network within your industry, attend industry events, and search for freelance writers on platforms like LinkedIn and industry-specific job boards. Look for writers who have previous experience working in your field or who have a proven track record of creating successful content for similar businesses.

What if I can’t afford to hire a full-time writer with industry expertise?

Consider hiring a freelance writer on a project basis or partnering with a content agency that specializes in your industry. You can also train your in-house experts to become better writers by providing them with writing training and support.

How important is SEO in content creation?

SEO is essential for ensuring that your content is discoverable by your target audience. Conduct keyword research to identify the terms that your audience is searching for and incorporate those keywords naturally into your content. Also, optimize your content for readability and user experience.

What metrics should I track to measure the success of my content marketing efforts?

Track metrics like organic traffic, time on page, bounce rate, conversion rates, social media engagement, and lead generation. These metrics will help you understand how your content is performing and identify areas for improvement.

How often should I publish new content?

The ideal publishing frequency depends on your industry, your audience, and your resources. However, as a general rule, aim to publish new content at least once a week to keep your website fresh and engage your audience.

Don’t settle for mediocre content that blends into the background. Invest in expertise, prioritize quality over quantity, and watch your marketing efforts soar. Start by identifying one piece of underperforming content on your website and task an expert to revise it this week.

Idris Calloway

Senior Marketing Strategist Certified Marketing Management Professional (CMMP)

Idris Calloway is a seasoned Marketing Strategist with over a decade of experience driving revenue growth for both startups and established corporations. As a Senior Marketing Strategist at Stellaris Innovations, he specializes in crafting data-driven campaigns that resonate with target audiences. He previously led digital marketing initiatives at Zenith Global Solutions, consistently exceeding key performance indicators. Idris is recognized for his expertise in brand building and customer acquisition strategies. Notably, he spearheaded a campaign that increased Stellaris Innovations' market share by 15% within a single quarter.