Press Release Fails: Avoid These Costly Marketing Traps

Crafting compelling press releases can feel like shouting into a hurricane, especially if you’re not getting the message right. Are you making mistakes that are costing you visibility and credibility? The difference between a press release that lands and one that flops often comes down to avoiding a few common pitfalls that can sink your marketing efforts.

Key Takeaways

  • Always include a specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound (SMART) goal for your press release, such as increasing website traffic by 15% within one month.
  • Back up all claims in your press release with credible data and sources, citing them directly within the release and linking to the original source.
  • Target your press release to a specific audience and tailor the language and content to resonate with their interests and needs, rather than using generic messaging.

I remember a few years ago, working with a small startup in the tech space here in Atlanta. They were launching a groundbreaking AI-powered tool for project management, and they were convinced their press release would make them an overnight sensation. They envisioned features in TechCrunch, Wired—the whole nine yards. They spent weeks crafting what they thought was the perfect announcement. The problem? It was a disaster.

Why? Let’s call the company “ProjectZen.” Their press release, while enthusiastic, was vague, filled with jargon, and completely devoid of anything that would grab a journalist’s attention. It was like reading a sales brochure, not a news announcement. The result? Crickets. Zero media pickup. Zip. Nada. They’d wasted time, effort, and a significant chunk of their marketing budget.

One of the biggest mistakes I see when crafting compelling press releases is a lack of a clear objective. ProjectZen’s goal was simply “to get noticed.” That’s not a goal; that’s a wish. A real goal should be specific. Do you want to drive traffic to your website? Increase brand awareness? Announce a new product launch and generate pre-orders? According to research from the Interactive Advertising Bureau (IAB), campaigns with clearly defined objectives are 47% more likely to achieve their desired outcomes. ProjectZen should have aimed for something like, “Increase website traffic by 20% within two weeks of the press release distribution.” This gives you a measurable benchmark to evaluate your success.

Another common mistake is failing to target the right audience. ProjectZen blasted their press release to a generic list of tech journalists, without considering their specific beats or interests. It’s like fishing with dynamite – you might catch something, but you’ll also scare away a lot of potential catches. Instead, identify the journalists and publications that specifically cover AI, project management, or startups in the Atlanta area. Tools like Cision or Meltwater can help you find relevant media contacts.

And speaking of Atlanta, consider leveraging local angles. Did ProjectZen partner with a local university, like Georgia Tech, for research and development? Did they hire a significant number of employees from the Atlanta area? Mentioning these details can make your press release more appealing to local media outlets, like the Atlanta Business Chronicle. It adds a human element and shows that your company is invested in the community.

Then there’s the issue of substance. ProjectZen’s press release was heavy on buzzwords and light on actual news. It talked about “disruptive innovation” and “synergistic solutions,” but it didn’t explain what their AI-powered tool actually did or how it benefited users. Journalists are looking for stories, not marketing fluff. Provide concrete examples, data, and testimonials to support your claims. For example, instead of saying “Our tool improves project efficiency,” say “Our tool reduces project completion time by an average of 15%, based on internal data from a pilot program with five clients.”

I had another client, a law firm downtown near the Fulton County Courthouse, that wanted to announce a new partner specializing in O.C.G.A. Section 34-9-1 (workers’ compensation law). Their initial draft was a dry recitation of the partner’s qualifications. We transformed it by focusing on a recent case where the partner secured a significant settlement for a local construction worker injured on the job. That human-interest angle made all the difference.

Here’s what nobody tells you: journalists are inundated with press releases every day. They’re looking for a reason to not read yours. Make it easy for them. Write a clear, concise headline that grabs their attention. Use bullet points to highlight key information. Include high-quality images or videos. And most importantly, make sure your press release is newsworthy. Ask yourself: would anyone outside your company care about this announcement?

One area where many press releases fall short is in providing adequate background information. The release should clearly state the company’s mission, its history (briefly), and its unique value proposition. Without this context, journalists may struggle to understand the significance of the announcement. A HubSpot study found that press releases with a strong company background are 23% more likely to be picked up by major media outlets.

Another pitfall is neglecting the call to action. What do you want readers to do after reading your press release? Visit your website? Download a white paper? Request a demo? Make it clear and easy for them to take the next step. Include relevant links and contact information. Don’t assume that journalists will know what to do next. Consider how informative content can drive leads.

Back to ProjectZen. After their initial failure, they came back to us for help. We completely revamped their marketing strategy and their approach to crafting compelling press releases. We helped them define clear, measurable goals, identify their target audience, and craft a compelling narrative that highlighted the benefits of their AI-powered tool. We focused on specific use cases and provided data to support their claims. We also helped them build relationships with relevant journalists in the tech space.

The result? Their next press release generated significant media coverage, including articles in several industry publications and a feature on a local news website. They saw a 35% increase in website traffic and a surge in sign-ups for their beta program. They learned the hard way that a well-crafted press release is a powerful tool for generating publicity and driving business growth. But it only works if you avoid the common mistakes that can derail your efforts. It’s not about blasting out a generic message to everyone; it’s about targeting the right audience with a compelling story that resonates with their interests and needs.

Crafting a press release that actually gets noticed requires more than just writing skills; it demands strategic thinking and a deep understanding of the media landscape. It’s about understanding what journalists are looking for and giving it to them in a clear, concise, and compelling way. Don’t make the same mistakes as ProjectZen. Invest the time and effort to craft a press release that truly stands out from the crowd.

To achieve media exposure, you might want to track your brand mentions effectively.

What is the ideal length for a press release?

Aim for around 400-500 words. Keep it concise and focused on the key message.

Should I include quotes in my press release?

Yes, quotes from key stakeholders (e.g., CEO, product manager) can add credibility and personality to your press release.

When is the best time to distribute a press release?

Tuesday and Wednesday mornings are generally considered the best times to send press releases, as journalists are more likely to be looking for stories at the start of the week.

How important are keywords in a press release?

Keywords are important for search engine optimization (SEO) and to help journalists find your press release when searching for specific topics. However, don’t stuff your press release with keywords – focus on writing naturally and incorporating relevant terms where appropriate.

What’s the difference between a press release and a media advisory?

A press release announces news, while a media advisory is a shorter, more concise document that alerts journalists to an upcoming event or opportunity.

Don’t let your next press release be another ignored announcement. Focus on crafting a targeted, newsworthy message with a clear call to action. Instead of aiming for general “awareness,” set a goal to increase qualified leads by 10% and track your results meticulously. That’s how you turn a press release from a cost center into a revenue driver. Also, be sure to avoid press release myths to improve your chances of success. Remember, the goal is to dominate media exposure!

Marcus Davenport

Senior Director of Brand Innovation Certified Marketing Management Professional (CMMP)

Marcus Davenport is a seasoned Marketing Strategist with over a decade of experience driving growth for leading organizations. He currently serves as the Senior Director of Brand Innovation at Stellar Marketing Solutions, where he spearheads the development and execution of integrated marketing campaigns. Prior to Stellar, Marcus held key leadership roles at Apex Digital Group. He is a recognized expert in digital marketing, brand strategy, and customer engagement, consistently delivering measurable results for his clients. Notably, Marcus led the team that achieved a 300% increase in lead generation for Stellar Marketing Solutions' flagship product in Q4 2022.